Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Rethinking Humanitarian Aid

My social studies class recently read a book called The Bottom Billion, written by Oxford Economics professor Paul Collier, which discusses four traps that keep the world’s poorest countries in poverty and what can be done to get them out of those traps and help them grow. I thought of Collier’s points when I saw this article by David Miliband on the Guardian’s Poverty Matters blog, entitled “It’s time to reassess the goals of humanitarian aid.” Mr. Miliband elaborates on three areas in which he believes we need to rethink foreign aid: doing away with the distinction between humanitarian institutions which address immediate crises and those working for long-term solutions to poverty, thinking about the modern needs of refugees and host communities, and making humanitarian goals for aid.

I found that Miliband’s first point about the decreasingly useful distinction between humanitarian groups for immediate and long-term assistance fit well with Collier’s theory of traps which keep countries impoverished. Collier’s traps are conflict, bad governance, natural resources, and being landlocked with bad neighbors. In this Poverty Matters article, Miliband says that because 50% of the world’s poor are in fragile and conflict-affected states, we shouldn’t categorize humanitarian aid into addressing either conflict or poverty. In our world, conflict is more and more directly linked to poverty, like Collier says when he names conflict one of the poverty traps. Miliband’s article gives the examples of Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Syria, and Zimbabwe, where an average of 75% of the entire population have been directly affected by conflict.

Both Collier and Miliband say that better coordinating foreign aid and reworking how it’s managed once it gets to poor countries will help us to fight poverty more effectively. Collier says that providers of humanitarian aid need to coordinate their efforts in order to make their aid more effective, and this lines up with Miliband’s call for humanitarian goals, or HuGos, in order to “get ahead of the curve” and plan how to address issues. Miliband also says that aid agencies need to address the specific needs of communities which support refugees, working with local officials and governments, another point which lines up with Collier’s ideas. Miliband says that this change in aid is necessary because refugees are increasingly living in urban or somewhat developed areas, putting a strain on those communities; also, refugee populations are growing larger than previously seen.

I found Collier’s and Miliband’s arguments about humanitarian aid to be compelling because they’re very timely; the conflicts in Syria and South Sudan strike me as the most recent ones I’ve heard much about, and I know they’ve thrown many into poverty and displacement. When the international community is dealing with so many conflicts which make people impoverished, it makes sense that we should look to new ways to think about aid in order to make humanitarian efforts as effective as possible.

Monday, March 3, 2014

Innovation with Hamlet

For the past month, my English class has been studying Shakespeare’s Hamlet. We read it a scene or two at a time, and after reading those bits we often took time in class to watch them performed by many different casts and directors. Seeing all of those different versions showed us just how much room for interpretation and creativity there is in a play. A multitude of interesting characters and relationships in Hamlet allowed for many of the variations: Did the actors portray Hamlet’s as crazed and depressed or crazed and angry? Was Ophelia rebellious or submissive? Was Polonius a caring father or a fool?

Another aspect of the play that left room for creativity was the setting. A lot of the versions we watched just set the play in Denmark in the era in which it was written, but a couple of them brought Hamlet into a modern setting. The Royal Shakespeare Company version sets the play in a castle in the 2000s, and the version from 2000 in which Ethan Hawke plays Hamlet takes place in a modern New York City, with Hamlet’s father as the C.E.O. of Denmark Corporation.

Those changes to the setting brought with them a lot of innovative twists to the Shakespeare play; our class had different opinions about whether we liked the changes or not. Both the RSC and Ethan Hawke versions use types of security devices like cameras, bugs, or one-way mirrors, which I thought was an interesting addition. I tend to think those sort of devices are just helpful technology for security, but in these productions of Hamlet I saw them in a more negative light since they’re sometimes used to spy on Hamlet. They also used guns instead of swords, which seems like a logical bridge between the play and modern life.

The Ethan Hawke version of Hamlet is the most different from what I would imagine of the play’s setting because it takes place in the middle of New York City. It’s cool to see how that version brings elements of modern life into the Hamlet story, but I think that a lot of the class felt, like I did, that certain things in this version were hard to connect with the original play. One was the fact that Hamlet’s family is supposed to be royalty in the play, whereas in this version his father was just a C.E.O. I think that royalty is important to the play because of the Great Chain of Being ideology, which includes the belief that a disruption of the social hierarchy with the monarchs at the top throws the whole state into chaos. I don’t think Americans today have the same belief about the C.E.O. and their whole company, although that could be grounds for discussion. Another leap is just simply the language; it takes a fair dose of suspension of disbelief for me to hear people in modern New York City using Shakespearean language and think it’s not really unusual. This is something that I noticed in our freshman year when we watched a modern version of Romeo and Juliet, too. When the play is in a modern setting, it becomes much harder for me to reconcile the Shakespearean language with the setting. Ultimately, these are creative leaps, though, and I do think that the changes they make to how one views Hamlet are valid and lead to an interesting discussion about how we interpret the play.

Sunday, March 2, 2014

Taking Opera Out of the Opera House

How does our experience of a performance change when it’s placed into a new setting? I wrote a bit about this question in my post from a couple of months ago about orchestras doing flash mob performances. I had seen a couple of videos in which full orchestras put on surprise performances outdoors or in a museum, and the startled people who gather into an audience don’t have to be formal and quiet; they point and talk and come and go as they please. It’s a completely different setting from a concert hall.

That initial question came to mind again when I read this article about the Gotham Chamber Opera, which has performed baroque operas in the Hayden Planetarium, a downtown nightclub, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and now the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Bloomberg Arms and Armor Court. They chose the settings because they fit with the settings of the operas: in the Planetarium, they did a Haydn opera about going to the moon, and in the Met’s Arms and Armor Court, they’re now performing Monteverdi’s “Il Combattimento di Tancredi e Clorinda,” which is about the battle between two knights where one turns out to be a woman.



When I read about the performance, I began to want to be there and see how the juxtaposition of the opera and the museum turned out. My first thought while reading about it was that being in the Arms and Armor Court probably would make the medieval setting of the opera more vivid and real for the audience. In the NYT article, there is a quote from the Met’s general manager of concerts and lectures, Limor Tomer, who says of performances in the museum, “the challenge is how to sort of engage with the galleries in ways that are authentic and meaningful and literally shine a new light on the objects.” It’s not just the opera that’s enriched, but the performance changes the way one sees the gallery, too. Maybe the story of the fight between Tancredi and Clorinda makes the armor seem more real as audiences imagine knights who would’ve worn it. The connection which these collaborators created between the gallery and the opera creates potential for the audience’s experience of both to grow richer.

In a way, the addition of the gallery as the setting of the performance seems like a second layer of setting for the opera.  This makes me think of this post my friend Nina wrote on her blog a while ago about the importance of setting in stories. The story’s already set for a medieval battle, regardless of where it is performed. First, that medieval setting provides the time and context in which audiences experience the opera’s story of the battle and the female knight. Second, the audience’s setting actually reinforces and adds to that first setting, since they’re surrounded by medieval objects and art. In placing the opera about a medieval battle inside the gallery of medieval armor, the Gotham Chamber Opera and the Met are emphasizing the unique setting in the story and also acknowledging the influence that the setting of a performance can have on the audience’s experience. The innovative connection between them adds to both the opera and the gallery.