My social studies class recently read a book called The Bottom Billion, written by Oxford Economics professor Paul Collier, which discusses four traps that keep the world’s poorest countries in poverty and what can be done to get them out of those traps and help them grow. I thought of Collier’s points when I saw this article by David Miliband on the Guardian’s Poverty Matters blog, entitled “It’s time to reassess the goals of humanitarian aid.” Mr. Miliband elaborates on three areas in which he believes we need to rethink foreign aid: doing away with the distinction between humanitarian institutions which address immediate crises and those working for long-term solutions to poverty, thinking about the modern needs of refugees and host communities, and making humanitarian goals for aid.
I found that Miliband’s first point about the decreasingly useful distinction between humanitarian groups for immediate and long-term assistance fit well with Collier’s theory of traps which keep countries impoverished. Collier’s traps are conflict, bad governance, natural resources, and being landlocked with bad neighbors. In this Poverty Matters article, Miliband says that because 50% of the world’s poor are in fragile and conflict-affected states, we shouldn’t categorize humanitarian aid into addressing either conflict or poverty. In our world, conflict is more and more directly linked to poverty, like Collier says when he names conflict one of the poverty traps. Miliband’s article gives the examples of Iraq, Libya, Somalia, Syria, and Zimbabwe, where an average of 75% of the entire population have been directly affected by conflict.
Both Collier and Miliband say that better coordinating foreign aid and reworking how it’s managed once it gets to poor countries will help us to fight poverty more effectively. Collier says that providers of humanitarian aid need to coordinate their efforts in order to make their aid more effective, and this lines up with Miliband’s call for humanitarian goals, or HuGos, in order to “get ahead of the curve” and plan how to address issues. Miliband also says that aid agencies need to address the specific needs of communities which support refugees, working with local officials and governments, another point which lines up with Collier’s ideas. Miliband says that this change in aid is necessary because refugees are increasingly living in urban or somewhat developed areas, putting a strain on those communities; also, refugee populations are growing larger than previously seen.
I found Collier’s and Miliband’s arguments about humanitarian aid to be compelling because they’re very timely; the conflicts in Syria and South Sudan strike me as the most recent ones I’ve heard much about, and I know they’ve thrown many into poverty and displacement. When the international community is dealing with so many conflicts which make people impoverished, it makes sense that we should look to new ways to think about aid in order to make humanitarian efforts as effective as possible.