It’s a regular day in a public place-- let’s say a street corner. People bustle around doing their own things. Parents shepherd children across the street; shopping bags rustle; there’s a general hum of voices and car sounds. One person carries a cello case, and, to the puzzlement of the people around him, he stops to unpack his instrument right in the middle of the sidewalk. When he’s set up, he begins to play. He quickly garners a few stares. Then a woman with a violin walks up next to him, and plays along. Soon a bassoonist, a viola player, and a flautist are part of the song. Piece by piece, the group grows into a full-fledged orchestra, and the crowd that clumps around them to watch is full of smiles.
The innovation of the flash mob has come to orchestral music. When I first saw a video of a singing flash mob online, I absolutely loved the idea. It’s hilarious to see passersby go from looks of surprise and curiosity to amazement when the whole group throws themselves into a well-planned performance. I also love the idea of bringing art into public places for free and for everyone. Performers in a flash mob offer up their talents just to brighten people’s day. Recently, I’ve seen a couple of flash mobs which brought entire orchestras out for the public to hear. The first, shown here, was a performance of the fourth movement of Beethoven’s 9th Symphony, or “Ode to Joy”, which started out with a single bass player acting like a street musician in Sabadell, Spain. Another was a performance of the U.S. Air Force Band inside the National Air and Space Museum in Washington, D.C. I love classical music, and seeing kids, families, and random people visiting a museum or walking down the street enjoy its beauty through these flash mobs makes me so happy.
There’s something about seeing a whole orchestra performing out in a public place that struck me as really significant, even though I’ve seen other flash mobs by choirs or groups of dancers (I think that dancers started the trend of the flash mob in the first place). It’s surprising to see any musical or dancing group out of their normal performing context, but for me, this feeling was especially powerful when the group was a classical orchestra. Along with loving to be in the audience, I play in the orchestra at my school, and I’ve grown accustomed to the world of black dresses and tuxedos, clapping when the conductor walks up to the podium, and silence between movements.
When the orchestra’s wearing t-shirts and casually begins playing among the noise of a bustling crowd, all of the formalities and silence of a concert hall seem to fly away, and all that’s left is a bunch of normal people enjoying art together. The orchestra members were a part of that crowd of people only a few minutes earlier. When they start playing, there are no rules saying that people can’t ooh and ah, or point at something that impresses them; no traditions that prevent small children from dancing around and flapping their arms like they’re conducting. The audiences of these flash mobs really seem to enjoy the performances, and they do so in a relaxed and spontaneous way.
Should classical music move away from traditions of silence and formality altogether? I don’t know. I’ve heard that opinion expressed before; this article from the Huffington Post is a good example. In his article, Richard Dare, the Managing Director of the Brooklyn Philharmonic, argues that orchestral audiences should be allowed to whoop, cheer, yell, and express themselves like they used to in the era of classical music’s origin. Audience members at a rock concert, he points out, have this privilege. Why not at a classical concert?
Personally, I see little that would be lost if the audience were allowed to react in whatever way they please at orchestra concerts. Maybe their noise would hamper others from hearing? I don’t think people would drown out the music because it’s what they came to hear. In making some noise, maybe audience members would connect to each other more than they do in silence, when they’re only allowed to enjoy the performance in their head.
Public and free enjoyment of music is why I love these orchestral flash mobs. Paying for tickets, dressing nicely, finding transportation, and sitting quietly for a three-hour orchestra concert in a big city isn’t possible for everyone. I certainly don’t think that classical music should completely abandon concert halls; musicians need to make money somehow. But it’s beautiful to hear music in the open air, and to see people talking, laughing, and sharing the experience with their families or friends. While the flash mob wasn’t originally an orchestral innovation, the trend is especially impactful when it brings the beauty of a classical orchestra into an everyday setting.
Hey Kathryn! I thought your post was so interesting and informative. I never heard of orchestral music being so informal and I like the fact that more and more people are growing akin to the idea. When I was little, my Mom took me to the symphony and I would get extremely bored while sitting in a stuffy concert hall. I don't think it was the music, it was just the constrained atmosphere. Classical music wasn't seen as something that could be actively enjoyed. However, when I came across live music, I felt a deeper connection to the audience and the music. I think orchestral flash mobs are an excellent idea, but they shouldn't replace the tradition of symphonic concerts, since there are people who enjoy a different type of environment.
ReplyDeleteI agree that Orchestral flash mobs are a great idea, and your point about doing away with the traditions of Orchestral music is an interesting one. Here is a link to a video of people allowing passerby to conduct them, which obviously did not always work out so well, but sometimes it was very cool.
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5_cbnBak8RI