How does our experience of a performance change when it’s placed into a new setting? I wrote a bit about this question in my post from a couple of months ago about orchestras doing flash mob performances. I had seen a couple of videos in which full orchestras put on surprise performances outdoors or in a museum, and the startled people who gather into an audience don’t have to be formal and quiet; they point and talk and come and go as they please. It’s a completely different setting from a concert hall.
That initial question came to mind again when I read this article about the Gotham Chamber Opera, which has performed baroque operas in the Hayden Planetarium, a downtown nightclub, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and now the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s Bloomberg Arms and Armor Court. They chose the settings because they fit with the settings of the operas: in the Planetarium, they did a Haydn opera about going to the moon, and in the Met’s Arms and Armor Court, they’re now performing Monteverdi’s “Il Combattimento di Tancredi e Clorinda,” which is about the battle between two knights where one turns out to be a woman.
When I read about the performance, I began to want to be there and see how the juxtaposition of the opera and the museum turned out. My first thought while reading about it was that being in the Arms and Armor Court probably would make the medieval setting of the opera more vivid and real for the audience. In the NYT article, there is a quote from the Met’s general manager of concerts and lectures, Limor Tomer, who says of performances in the museum, “the challenge is how to sort of engage with the galleries in ways that are authentic and meaningful and literally shine a new light on the objects.” It’s not just the opera that’s enriched, but the performance changes the way one sees the gallery, too. Maybe the story of the fight between Tancredi and Clorinda makes the armor seem more real as audiences imagine knights who would’ve worn it. The connection which these collaborators created between the gallery and the opera creates potential for the audience’s experience of both to grow richer.
In a way, the addition of the gallery as the setting of the performance seems like a second layer of setting for the opera. This makes me think of this post my friend Nina wrote on her blog a while ago about the importance of setting in stories. The story’s already set for a medieval battle, regardless of where it is performed. First, that medieval setting provides the time and context in which audiences experience the opera’s story of the battle and the female knight. Second, the audience’s setting actually reinforces and adds to that first setting, since they’re surrounded by medieval objects and art. In placing the opera about a medieval battle inside the gallery of medieval armor, the Gotham Chamber Opera and the Met are emphasizing the unique setting in the story and also acknowledging the influence that the setting of a performance can have on the audience’s experience. The innovative connection between them adds to both the opera and the gallery.
Hey Kathryn,
ReplyDeleteCool post! I always thought it was important to place more traditional performances in non-traditional settings. So many people miss out on spectacular pieces of art by not having the money or the initial interest to see it. However, if we start putting performances in places such as parks and museums, people would be acquainted with important aspects of culture. Not to mention, it is a wonderful artistic experience when combining beautiful scenery like paintings or nature with music.